In the hierarchy

1. Part II: Societal & Human Concerns
2. D11. Malicious Use & Weaponization
3. 11.3 CBRN uplift

Virtues and principles to explore

Held as inquiry, not as a verdict.

• Courage

  Hope

  Act without the comfort of certainty.

• Stewardship

  Service

  Hold what is built in trust for those who will live with it.

• Prudence

  Excellence

  Small, reversible steps before irreversible ones.

Starter questions

Written to probe curiosity and learning, not accusation.

1. 01If we named this complication in advance, what small, reversible step would let us learn?
2. 02How would we know we were getting this wrong? What would we observe, without blaming a person?
3. 03What would trustworthiness look like here: what we do, what we say, and the belief others form?
4. 04What would it look like if we held “Automated lab misuse” with proportion rather than alarm?

Also on this branch

• Biological synthesis uplift10
• DNA-synthesis-order screening evasion10
• Chemical-weapon design uplift10
• Radiological device design uplift10
• Nuclear-weapon knowledge acquisition10
• Dual-use scientific research risks20

Frameworks and sources

• MIT AI Incident Trackerincidents
• MITRE ATLASframework
• International humanitarian law (IHL)framework

  The body of law that governs the conduct of armed conflict and the protection of people who are not fighting, which applies to AI used in or for conflict.